Suggestions wanted: Forum categories

mbieweng
Posts: 355
Joined: 2006-10-31
Dad Points: 1056

Look here:

http://www.athomedad.org/forum

These are the current forum categories. Most everything ends up in "general discussion". I'd like to have things be a bit more organized. Should the categories be different? If so, what should they be?

I want to aim for a small number of categories that are general and large-scale with minimal overlap. For example "parenting", "marriage", etc rather than "food issues", "diaper issues", "sleep issues", etc

I'll suggest this to get started:

General Discussion and Socializing
Parenting
Marriage
Hobbies, Projects, etc
Culture, Entertainment, Sports, etc
Website Discussion and Suggestions
Convention




JohnGilroy
Posts: 195
Joined: 2007-04-25
Dad Points: 309
Marriage

Good idea but how about "relationships" or something rather than "marriage" since not everyone is married.



randyfielding
randyfielding's picture
Posts: 317
Joined: 2007-02-05
Dad Points: 354
I like your list Mike.

Looks great to me!

Randy
Cincinnati, OH
SAHD to Ryder (23 months)



Gaming with Baby
Gaming with Baby's picture
Posts: 481
Joined: 2007-08-15
Dad Points: 682
You keep asking for ideas

I'll keep throwing them out.

New SAHDs Welcome and Information- Welcome to AtHomeDad.org! We encourage new members to stop by and introduce themselves. (Subtopic board- SAHD News, Local SAHD Groups)
Ask a SAHD- Do you have a burning question that only a fellow stay-at-home dad can answer? Ask here to find out what your fellow SAHDs think in regards to parenting, relationships, and issues specific to the everyday life (Subtopic boards- Marriage, Relationships)
At Home Dad's Convention- Information regarding the annual At Home Dad's Convention
General Discussions- For all those off-topics and irrelevant discussions that making connecting with other SAHDs so much fun. (Subtopic boards- Culture, Entertainment, Sports, Hobbies & DIY, Humor, Recipes)
Website Issues & Discussion- Please report any suggestions, complaints, or ideas regarding AtHomeDad.org here.

*Create a dedicated entry page to the site with links to information for media, the forums, and other areas of the site.
*Create subtopics for the forums.
*Add a search function to the forums.
*Add the ability to PM forum members.
*Trim the tabs at the top of the page. You've got a ton of redundancy and mostly unused tabs there.
*Eliminate the "What's new at AtHomeDad.org" box from the main entry page or change it to reflect member posted news stories, blog titles, convention information, etc.
*Add a donation button on the main page. For example in the AtHomeDad.org Supporters box.
*If you aren't getting any revenue from the Google AdSense applet, lose it. The ads are rarely relevant. "Are You A Slacker Mom?" Last time I checked, I don't have ovaries.

There they are. Good or bad, those are my ideas.

-Will
http://www.gamingwithbaby.com all your diapers are belong to us
fatdadcooking.com coming soon!
my flickr



CiaAlum92
CiaAlum92's picture
Posts: 504
Joined: 2007-12-19
Dad Points: 1477
I think it was posted already?

A post for expertise help. I know we have web geeks and carpenters and plumbers and some self proclaimed professionals in all sorts of other trades, before we were AHD's. Lets pick their brains in a forum just for Ask the pro.....
Kevin

http://web.mac.com/ciaalum92/SAHD_Man/Welcome.html

Please refrain for calling me "Mr. Mom" I now Prefer-- Domestic Overlord



mbieweng
Posts: 355
Joined: 2006-10-31
Dad Points: 1056
New revision

Ok, thanks everyone. The forum topic suggestions are great.

Will, your other ideas are fine and welcome too, but I'm going to defer them for right now in favor of focusing on the issue at hand.

Here's a new revision that incorporates the above along with my own ideas. They are topics and subtopics but otherwise in no particular order:

New members welcome and introduction
General Discussion and Socializing
-Culture and Entertainment
-Sports
-Hobbies & DIY
-Humor
-Everything else
Ask a dad
-Parenting
-Relationships
-Professional and trade questions
-Other questions
Website Discussion and Suggestions
Convention



JPhillip
JPhillip's picture
Posts: 654
Joined: 2006-11-17
Dad Points: 940
List is good.

I would separate the DIY category and move it down to join Professional and Trade questions, e.g., "DIY, Professional and Trade Questions"



Gaming with Baby
Gaming with Baby's picture
Posts: 481
Joined: 2007-08-15
Dad Points: 682
DIY could easily go both ways

Wait a minute, does that sound dirty to anyone else? :)

That looks great.

-Will
http://www.gamingwithbaby.com all your diapers are belong to us
fatdadcooking.com coming soon!
my flickr



dkremers_1965
dkremers_1965's picture
Posts: 266
Joined: 2007-09-28
Dad Points: 470
My 2 Cents

I think this sounds good. I hope in the reorganizing we don't lose the anonymous ability for those that need to ask something but are too embarrassed to just ask it.

Check out my ramblings on life at http://www.sahdguy.blogspot.com/



ticktock
ticktock's picture
Posts: 703
Joined: 2006-11-06
Dad Points: 1202
I'm confused about DIY

I'm confused about DIY Hobbies forum. What is the line of discussion that will stem from that category? The reason I ask is because I thought it might be nice to have a section for games, crafts, and other fun parenting tips, and I was wondering if that would fit in the DIY category.

You may want to think about having a sub-forum for politics, religion, and other sensitive issues. That way you can head off any drama by letting it have it's own designated place.

Is it possible to color code the side bar thread previews? So that if a thread title is red, you know it's a certain category. That might be complicated, I bet.

It drives me crazy that the board forces a post to have a subject line. You can't leave it blank (see above). Add that to my list of annoying suggestions for down the road. :)

Have you thought about farming out some of the work? I bet there would be volunteers to help with programming. Afterall, this isn't profitable to you, so take all the help you can get. I'm an idiot. Don't ask me for help. But there are quite a few programmers in the AHD ranks.



CiaAlum92
CiaAlum92's picture
Posts: 504
Joined: 2007-12-19
Dad Points: 1477
What was the call on a live chat room

I know we discussed this before. But we now have everybody undivided attention...

Kevin

http://web.mac.com/ciaalum92/SAHD_Man/Welcome.html

Please refrain for calling me "Mr. Mom" I now Prefer-- Domestic Overlord



MileHiDad
MileHiDad's picture
Posts: 592
Joined: 2006-11-06
Dad Points: 1139
How About

Healthy Living
It could be anything from fitness for dad and kids, healthy food ideas to specific bike trails/hiking trail/fitness paths that people should try that are kid friendly if they are ever passing through. With the rise in obesity in both kids and adults, we should be proactive about it!

My Site, http://www.milehidad.com/ and my Blog, http://www.milehighdad.net/, visit my online Dad store at my Blog!
Make Babies, Not War!
I Wanna Know How Forever Feels...



mbieweng
Posts: 355
Joined: 2006-10-31
Dad Points: 1056
Healthy living

Who has time for healthy living? :-) I thought everyone gave up their former running careers and just drank beer and whiskey now...

I like the idea to move the DIY. (By the way, it's only becomes dirty if it's a subcategory of "relationships")

The crafts, etc can go in parenting or one of the general discussion categories. If there's a lot of this we can always make a separate place for it, but there's been very little thus far. I don't want to have a category with no posts.

Not much change, but here:

New members welcome and introduction
General Discussion and Socializing
-Culture and Entertainment
-Sports
-Hobbies
-Humor
-Everything else
Ask a dad
-Parenting
-Relationships
-Professional, trade, and DIY questions
-Other questions
Website Discussion and Suggestions
Convention



MileHiDad
MileHiDad's picture
Posts: 592
Joined: 2006-11-06
Dad Points: 1139
The 3 H's

Didn't You Know?
Single Malt Scotch keeps you healthy, horney and happy?

My Site, http://www.milehidad.com/ and my Blog, http://www.milehighdad.net/, visit my online Dad store at my Blog!
Make Babies, Not War!
I Wanna Know How Forever Feels...



paddyrat
paddyrat's picture
Posts: 194
Joined: 2007-08-13
Dad Points: 254
who you callin' fat??

MileHi,

I either have:

a. A thyroid problem.
b. Big bones.
c. Dunlap's disease.

(besides, when SOME cougars are on the prowl, they're not that picky... LOL)

I used LOL and I feel somehow less sarcastic; oh well, following the new forum guidelines like a good boy.

Aye, there's nary an animal alive that can outrun a greased scotsman...



MileHiDad
MileHiDad's picture
Posts: 592
Joined: 2006-11-06
Dad Points: 1139
Paddymon, WhazUp?

All you need is motivation.

My Site, http://www.milehidad.com/ and my Blog, http://www.milehighdad.net/, visit my online Dad store at my Blog!
Make Babies, Not War!
I Wanna Know How Forever Feels...



dkremers_1965
dkremers_1965's picture
Posts: 266
Joined: 2007-09-28
Dad Points: 470
Live Chat or PM

I'm all for the live chat or Private Messenger. What a great way to talk more directly to each other.

Check out my ramblings on life at http://www.sahdguy.blogspot.com/



JPhillip
JPhillip's picture
Posts: 654
Joined: 2006-11-17
Dad Points: 940
IM or chat

If you are into that type of communication, just exchange your regular instant messenger screen id with other guys here. No sense in reinventing the wheel. Mike has limited time and resources at this point.



New No.2
New No.2's picture
Posts: 531
Joined: 2007-11-12
Dad Points: 747
Polotics

I have a thought.
NO POLOTICS!
I come here, or came here, to this site to talk to other Dads about parenting and the unusual position we are in in society. A lot of noise has been made about "we are all adults" and this being and "Oasis," she here is my noise. We are all adults so I'm sure we can suspend discussion of our politics no matter how much it pains us. This is an oasis? Hardly. I don't feel that I can let my guard down anymore or be myself. I used to feel very comfortable with everyone on this board but now I feel constantly on guard. I know I can leave and I may very well do that.

I'm sniped at enough in my life and it makes me furious to be sniped at here when I thought we were all in the same boat and were visiting this site for mutual support and understanding. A deviation from time to time is fun but look at the side bar, how many topics are there about being an AHD?

We all don’t have to like each other per se but ya know what “we are all adults,” and I’m sure we can keep things civilized. I say this because this site is becoming the locker room I have been leaving my whole life and I am feeling I need to leave again. I don’t want to because this site used to make me feel a little more confident that my problems weren’t uniqe and better men than I had been down the same road and came out smiling. Now I feel like a duck at a carnival shooting gallery waiting for a pellet to knock me down, or for someone to start pulling down towels and demanding, no matter his size, that his cock is the biggest, loudest or more obnoxious than mine.

I am now whole heartedly for a moderator and a few, but strictly enforced, guidelines.

And yes I am sensitive, but “we are all adults,” so if some of you are cavalier and happy go lucky, or just plain loud, you should understand that I am not.

Be Seeing You.



JPhillip
JPhillip's picture
Posts: 654
Joined: 2006-11-17
Dad Points: 940
NewNo2

I for one, have always enjoyed your posts here. The one about the quiet walk up the mountain and a relaxing drink at the top was a really nice image for me.

I will tell you a little secret about many of the guys here: We all have vulnerabilities. I have even seen some of them in person at the convention. Please don't get your guard up or feel like the next shot could come at any time.

You are welcome here, and I would really hate to see you go. Also, if you don't see anything that you like in the current threads, just start a new one! It's easy to give and take. And, never ever click on anything that looks like politics. : )

Peace, bro.



ticktock
ticktock's picture
Posts: 703
Joined: 2006-11-06
Dad Points: 1202
You're over-reacting

Don't turn this into another situation where you are making yourself the victim. These are just discussions. There have been very few curse words and no personal insults. People will debate issues. It's not about you, nobody here knows you, and everyone has been respectful toward you.

We are all at-home Dads. We live it every day. We don't need to talk about Dad issues all the time. People should be free to discuss whatever subject they wish to discuss in a respectful way.



paddyrat
paddyrat's picture
Posts: 194
Joined: 2007-08-13
Dad Points: 254
#2, Delicately as possible

I would much rather have a hotly charged debate over politics than music in this forum simply because politics does have an underlying effect on what I do as an AHD and the future of my children and music does not. That puts us all in the same boat as a group and my hope is that although politics does rub some folks the wrong way, it can be discussed intelligently amongst these pages as it pertains to our families. I sympathize with your concern about the "locker room" mindset as I too have some lingering issues about being accepted by my peers, but please continue to be a part of this forum as I find some of your insights to be valuable to what we are all about.

Anyone can pull my towel down, because the Irish, God love 'em, were blessed with stout livers, not stout penises...

Aye, there's nary an animal alive that can outrun a greased scotsman...



dkremers_1965
dkremers_1965's picture
Posts: 266
Joined: 2007-09-28
Dad Points: 470
New No. 2

Hey guy, I hear what you are saying. In case you haven't figured it out yet, I'm not your typical guy when it comes to what I like and I have been fighting against what other guys think of me (or a lack of acceptance from other guys) for years. Yes, sometimes I feel it here too, but when that happens I just have to remember that we all need our outlets. I would agree that some of the ways some of the guys vent in here can seem mean to me, but it's just their way. I don't want them to judge me for how I am so I have to set the example and not judge them for their style/way of venting. I know it's hard to do that sometimes but that's what I have to do. If that won't work for you, that's fine, I'm just saying what I do. What ever you decide to do, I hope you do stick around because it's good for all of us in here to see other views and opinions on different things. I stuck with it in here and I have a couple of dads that I have become good friends with; we actually talk almost everyday and enjoy the time we have those conversations. I really hope you do stick with it in here, it can be a great place to just get help for things, see other views on things, and even make some friends you would never have made before.

Check out my ramblings on life at http://www.sahdguy.blogspot.com/



JPhillip
JPhillip's picture
Posts: 654
Joined: 2006-11-17
Dad Points: 940
DK

Did I mention that I am sorry if I offended you in the past?



Jim L
Jim L's picture
Posts: 118
Joined: 2006-11-12
Dad Points: 168
That's the beauty of it

New #2,

Those types of concerns are exactly why there SHOULD be a forum just for politics.

If you never want to open that folder, you never have to see it. People who enjoy debating candidates or policies or whatever can cut loose in that forum.

Politics will show up eventually, especially in an election year, and IME, there are few things that SAHDs disagree about more than politics, since we are such a diverse group. It might as well have it's own place instead of creeping into other threads.

Stick around through the growing pains.



alenaspoppa
alenaspoppa's picture
Posts: 223
Joined: 2007-11-27
Dad Points: 316
Me too

Ditto what JPhillip said.



dkremers_1965
dkremers_1965's picture
Posts: 266
Joined: 2007-09-28
Dad Points: 470
JPhillip and alenaspoppa,

JPhillip and alenaspoppa, don't sweat it. I'm so over it (and knew you guys were just giving me a hard time). I enjoy talking with you guys too much to hold a grudge. Besides, I'd hate to be nasty about it and appear as a character in Eric's next book...lmao! I can see it now...Alena and the Nasty Grudge Holding SAHD. Ummmmm....I think not. LOL! And JPillip how we going to have a wine cooler at the next convention if I hold it against you? That wouldn't be much fun! Oh...and I like the fuzzy navel ones. Good stuff, Maynard!

Check out my ramblings on life at http://www.sahdguy.blogspot.com/



New No.2
New No.2's picture
Posts: 531
Joined: 2007-11-12
Dad Points: 747
Thanks all, And I'm sure I

Thanks all,
And I'm sure I will stick around.
I don't feel as if I'm any kind of victim. If I did I would have left quietly and that would be that. What I did do was express myself. It seemed to me that a few voices had a monopoly on the debate over how the site should grow and evolve. I looked at the site with fresh eyes the other day and wondered if, given it's current state, I would join to talk with y'all, myself included, and thought I probably wouldn't. I am just as culpable as everyone else for ill behavior and improper posts.

However, the squeaky wheel gets the grease and I wanted to squeak as loudly as I could, because I do believe it is important that new Dads feel that they are welcome to post with sensitive issues and be able to talk about the isolation we all feel.

I believe, but could be wrong, that men like TickTock, and Gaming w/ Babay have clearly articulated what he feels the site should be and how he sees it playing a roll in his life. It’s great that they have been so vocal but I felt that there are other voices less articulate and perhaps less confident that needed to be heard. I'm not intending to sound like a martyr or a "voice of the people," gut my personal view and the value I put on this site was expressed and I’m told “I’m overreacting.” But I was heard and I'm glad I was. I want this site to flourish as much as the rest of you but for me, I need a spot to take a breather, and joke a little and ask wiser men then myself, JPhillip, Paddyrat, ect. questions about parenting.

I hope this explains my recent behavior.
Jonathan



JonMcP
JonMcP's picture
Posts: 303
Joined: 2007-01-03
Dad Points: 460
221 Guests???

Not trying to get off topic, but I think this may be a little relevant- I just looked over at the "Who's Online" status box and it's currently listing 6 users and 221 guests. Could that be accurate? Good lord that's a lot of hits.



mbieweng
Posts: 355
Joined: 2006-10-31
Dad Points: 1056
Yes

There are limits to that counter's accuracy, but it's more or less accurate. There are a lot of lurkers...



ticktock
ticktock's picture
Posts: 703
Joined: 2006-11-06
Dad Points: 1202
Serious about this...

"Now I feel like a duck at a carnival shooting gallery waiting for a pellet to knock me down, or for someone to start pulling down towels and demanding, no matter his size, that his cock is the biggest, loudest or more obnoxious than mine."

I misinterpreted your above comments as an over-reaction and victimization. I'm sorry if I got that wrong. For real.

Could you clarify when you felt like a discussion involved sniping directed at you? I'm actually confused about that accusation. I don't remember many threads at all with anyone being sniped at, aside from the music thread which didn't involve you.

I seriously want to know where this momentum against the content of the discussion has come from. It isn't how I see the forum at all lately.

One expects banter and sniping on discussion boards, and these boards are relatively tame compared to other places. It really blows my mind that the conversations here are even considered to be harsh and uninviting.



Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.