I challenge the popular idea that mozart will make your kids smarter here.
Basically, there has never been a Mozart-intelligence study done on kids, and the research that sparked the idea of "The Mozart Effect" was flawed and later exploited.
I challenge the popular idea that mozart will make your kids smarter here.
Basically, there has never been a Mozart-intelligence study done on kids, and the research that sparked the idea of "The Mozart Effect" was flawed and later exploited.

Someone bought one of those CD's for me years ago, swearing that her idiot daughter was racking up IQ points like some people collect Yu-Gi-Oh cards. I copied it off (deleting some drivel at the start of the CD about "it's amazing effects on my kids!"). Well, the music was nice. But Mozart makes you smarter? Ha!
I only wish I would've thought this one up first, made my fortune, and laughed all the way to the bank.
And I completely agree with your assessment that learning to play an instrument will have a more positive effect on a child.
Sorry that I can't disagree with you on this. :-)
(P.S. -- Have you ever looked at the Sponsored Links that Google arbitrarily places to the left? Yeah. Over there. "Mozart Effect" items for sale? "Classic Harp Sheet Music"? "Are You a Slacker Mom?" And then "Fire Your Boss"? What ads did they give you? -- And Mike, Nope! I'm not criticizing this website at all, nor faulting you. I vaguely know how that randomness-thing works. It's just kinda funny how different companies want a piece of your action.)

I think and this is purely opinion with zero research, but when things get down to marketing and product sales, as in the extremely popular Baby Einstein, now being pawned by disney, there are going to be "research studies" and, like TT wrote in his blog, 38 children is too low for a good study, to help increase sales and the marketing position of certain things. The sad outcome to all of this is that some parents are looking for the quick fix to increase their childrens intelligence without having to do anything. Just plop them down in front of the TV or leave them in their room with Mozart playing and presto You will have a smarter kid. Parenting is an active role with no quick fixes. As we all now it takes weeks or months to teach a new skill, and if there was a CD out there that could teach a 8 month old how to feed themselves with a spoon I would have to say I would not buy it. I want my child to experience the way and things daddy and mommy like. We listen to all forms of music . My son is active with me while I play guitar, some bongos at his feet for him to bang on or I will just hold the chords and he can explore and strum the strings. I read whatever I am reading outloud. I explain how and what I am cooking. Point...there are too many variables that Mozart cannot teach. Will someone be smarter if influenced by Mozart. Maybe, but it is the whole picture that matters.

with the Mozart stuff is that it gets reinforced strongly by anectodal evidence in the form of "How did Billy get so smart?" "Oh, we played Mozart for him when he was a baby." Billy's parents also happen to be affluent and educated themselves, and the impact their education on Billy's intelligence level never gets considered as a contributing factor in these little anectdotal experiments.
Smart parents often raise smart children; smart parents also happen to listen to Mozart on occasion. The causation-correlation fallacy runs deep.
http://backpackingdad.blogspot.com


I remember my wife and I listening to Mozart's "Jupiter" symphony once while she was pregnant with our first son. Later, when he was just a few weeks old, I played my entire CD set of The Marriage of Figaro for him. Finally, the other day we heard about five minutes of The Magic Flute in our van. Now, at just 4 and a half years old, he can do 100 piece jigsaw puzzles in less than an hour.
Coincidence? I think not.

Recently, a small team of scientists and music historians were permitted to enter Mozart's tomb. When they entered, they were shocked to discover him sitting at a small table with sheet music in one hand and a giant eraser in his other hand.
The lead scientist blurted out, "Oh my God, what are you doing in here?" With glaring eyes, Mozart violently waved the eraser at the man and said, "Decomposing, you idiot!"

This is a way to introduce many parents to a different kind of music. Maybe it'll also be good for the kids. And what a better way to hear music. I don't disagree with your statement, but I guess if parent are able to enjoy Mozart (or other classical composers), there is a chance that their kids will enjoy classical music too (Mozart included), and that can help them to be more focused.
======================
Congratatio pro erudio et auxilium
Itux

"but I guess if parent are able to enjoy Mozart (or other classical composers), there is a chance that their kids will enjoy classical music too (Mozart included), and that can help them to be more focused"
And this is my hangup, Itux. I don't think most of those sorts of parents can actually enjoy Mozart. I think a goodly number of them get caught up in the "scientific research" of making smarter babies, and then they throw all this art and music and literature at their kids, thinking they will eventually unlock some reincarnation of Degas or Hemingway hidden deep inside their child.
Essentially, the parents who are sucked into these Einstein CDs, etc., aren't "enjoying the music." They are too involved in a frantic search for their children's genius-ness-esque. (I love making new words.)
To me, and only to me, mind you, it diminishes the greatness of the work of art, whether it is an opera, a sonata, a painting, or sculpture, etc. And I love my artsy-fartsy stuff.
I just don't see people getting the appreciation when they scramble for IQ points. Nor do they get IQ points. I just wish they could love art and not merely it's potential on their child. THAT, my dear man, is where I think kids benefit: from seeing their parents appreciate Mozart and, then, appreciating it on their own.

A couple of years ago my daughter painted a Degas in her bedroom, of course the medium she chose was poop, but it was a blue period for her.... Oh you guys just don't understand ART!!!
db
Father of three,
Mac (6), Tavie(4), and Buddy(3)
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Denver_Dad/

My 4 year old likes The Beastie Boys, AC/DC and Led Zeppelin and has been reading since he was 2!
/seriously!
Joined: 2006-11-06
Dad Points: 1255