So since Im an AHD I, as you know, occasionally have time to think. I've been thinking bailout. Here's my plan. Discuss, hate, discuss, love, discuss....
So my concern with the bailout as it is focused currently is that it simply transfers financial problems from financial institutions to the US government. Actually homeowners with bad mortgages (or any mortgages) are not helped at all. Plus the money then given to financial institutions is not guaranteed to rush back into the system, or if it does we have to wait, once again for "trickle down" to us folks.
So here is my plan (with TONS of holes):
* Pay off our mortgages. Give every household $100,000. Not per house, just $100,000 for a primary residence. There is no income limit (if we insist on one make it $500K).
* By reducing mortgages by $100K you not only give homewowners much needed relief by reducing the payments per month you also eliminate years of interest payments. So the $100K is more like $120K (give or take).
* If my wife and I had $100K less to pay off on our mortgage I guarantee you we would spend money on a) buying things for the house, b) fixing up the house, c) reducing credit card debt or d) saving more. Any of these options are what economists have hoped from families, spend more, get out of debt, or save more.
* For those who have already paid off a mortgage? Since many of them are probably Baby Boomers or seniors give them $25K per household for health insurance or retirement (since much of latter was probably wiped out). Make it $50K...I don't know.
* Give renters a buying credit. Give them $50K towards a down payment. Don't relax borrowing requirements but having that money for a down payment is HUGE. I know that for many of my friends and peers the toughest part of home buying isn't the payment, it's the down payment.
* If someone rents and doesn't want to buy a house? I don't know. How about $10K for retirement, too?
OK so here are the problems:
* How far does $700B go towards this?
* How do we eliminate loopholes? We don't want Cindy McCain to get $100K for her house and John to get one for his.
* Yes, stupid people who made stupid decisions get money for a mortgage they shouldn't have had. But right now stupid companies, who have smarter employees, one hopes, are getting a LOT more than $100K
Here are the positives:
* Banks, mortgage companies AND individuals all get money out of this. And families benefit the most immediately (cash) and in the future (reduction of interest)
* Money gets back into the economy. $1500 doesn't stimulate anything, most friends I know spent that $$ on gas, debt, or put it in the bank. Tens of thousands? That is enough to spark some spending.
* If we are going into debt as a nation anyway and the tax payers have to bear the burden shouldn't they receive the reward?
* Finally what congress person doesn't want to stand in front of a mic and say "We're going to give the money back to you"?
Thanks for reading. It may be irrelevant bunk but it's been sticking in my head.





Joined: 2006-11-13
Dad Points: 530