Cold Medicines

shuaevan
shuaevan's picture
Posts: 202
Joined: 2006-11-13
Dad Points: 522

Here is the latest on the cold medicine for kid update.

Drug companies say no cold medicines...

OK call me a heartless jerk. But of the millions of children out in the US who have taken cold medicines under the age of 4....1500 have gone to the ER and 3 have died. It's tragic when ANY child dies of course but that is a tiny number for us to ban cold medicines.

I've used them on my then infant son, and they work. Can't be placebo since a 12 month old doesn't know what a placebo is. And we thinik that the people who couldn't read instructions BEFORE on bottles are going to be more careful now when they grab whatever cold medicine they can find to give to their kid? Do we want them to try and do the math on dividing dosages meant for a 6 year old? At least before you had a dropper, it's hard to accidentally give an overdose with that...unless you give repeated applications of the drugs...which I know family's have done b/c they don't communicate what's been given or they panic and try more when something doesn't work. I think this is screaming for even more problems.

Thus ends the venting.




journeyoftheanimals
Posts: 14
Joined: 2008-10-05
Dad Points: 41
Link not working, but this

Link not working, but this sounds very interesting.



shuaevan
shuaevan's picture
Posts: 202
Joined: 2006-11-13
Dad Points: 522
Fixed the link...

Thanks for the heads up JOTA

Josh

SAHD Since August 2005



journeyoftheanimals
Posts: 14
Joined: 2008-10-05
Dad Points: 41
Well I can see both sides of

Well I can see both sides of the argument. But I would say that most deaths related to cold medicine would be due to overdosing. Does this mean it should all be taken off the shelves or something? Most deaths caused by alcohol are caused by overdosing too (drinking and driving, and other stuff) should we pull all the alcohol too? OK maybe not the best example. But no matter what people do, they are still going to give meds to very young children. My question is why wouldn't it help?



phaze-3
phaze-3's picture
Posts: 73
Joined: 2007-01-03
Dad Points: 142
We have a small repertoire

There are only a few meds that I've found work well, and we've used them quite sparingly -- Delsym for coughs, children's Claritin for runny nose, and Motrin Cold for fever and congestion. The only inconvenience is getting the Motrin from behind the pharmacy counter and giving my driver's license each time because, as you know, I obviously run a meth lab in my spare time.

You would think we traffic in colds all the time, since DW is exposed to all sorts of stuff, but we rarely get sick. I've become a huge fan of a generic version of Airborne, which DD can take as a half-dose. I swear it keeps the bugs away. That and being sticklers about hand washing. Homeschooling sure doesn't hurt, either, although I'm wary of the psycho moms who don't vaccinate their kids.

That Homeschooling Dad
Homeschool Hut



JohnGilroy
Posts: 281
Joined: 2007-04-26
Dad Points: 429
Chicken Soup

Since these "remedies" can't actually cure the cold what are they doing that tylenol on it's own (or chicken soup) doesn't?
There could be a placebo effect if the parents tell the kid, "this is going to make you feel better" or if the kid reacts to a change in parents behaviour after they administer the "medicine", a bit like the sugar/hyperactivity thing.



ticktock
ticktock's picture
Posts: 772
Joined: 2006-11-06
Dad Points: 1344
...

I'd say it's the hand washing that keeps the bugs away, not the Airborne. That company recently had to pay a big settlement because it lied about being able to prevent colds.

Cold medicine may work well enough, but cough medicine only has 2/5 ingredients that are effective. Studies have shown that a spoonful of honey works better.
..........................................
http://www.altparenting.com



phaze-3
phaze-3's picture
Posts: 73
Joined: 2007-01-03
Dad Points: 142
Definitely the ingredients

I think the big difference is expectations. No meds will eliminate the cold, but they will reduce specific symptoms, which should be the goal. Parents who think cold meds will actually get rid of a cold are dimwits, and most likely are the ones who need some sort of hand-holding from on high.

That Homeschooling Dad
Homeschool Hut



Electriclime
Electriclime's picture
Posts: 107
Joined: 2008-06-20
Dad Points: 140
Quick fix

My wife, a pharmacist, has been complaining about parents with sick kids for a long time and is glad this news came out. Parents are constantly coming in telling her their kids are 'sick.' Symptoms? The have a 'cold.' She explains that if it is severe they need to take their kids to a doctor and if it is not she suggests some things to soothe their symptoms since it will just take time to get over a common cold. The parents don't want to hear any of that; they want a solution in a bottle and they want it NOW. She also gets a lot of people who have leftover prescription medication they didn't finish and want to give it to their kids. They are so desperate for a quick fix that they don't think about how small their little child is and what would be best for them. They get upset at my wife and grab something off the shelf. It will be interesting to see if this trend is affected by the new warnings or if the parents just get more frustrated.

Like Phaze-3 said; these people need a lot of hand holding.

Rich C. : Novice baby wrangler and cat herder.
http://one-sahd-dude.blogspot.com/
http://good-eats-fan.blogspot.com/
http://www.flickr.com/photos/onesahddude/



Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.